To Speak With One Of Our Agents About Insurance For Your Business Call Today!  1(800) 606-6221

W. Tyler Compton

Tyler Compton began his insurance career in 2004.  Tyler joined Tilton, Thomas & Morgan in 2010, working as a Commercial Lines Producer and immediately began working in the bowling program at the agency.  He first attended Bowl Expo in 2012 and has been an attendee every year since, working with proprietors throughout the United States. Tyler has developed a specialized working knowledge of the insurance challenges proprietors face and what it takes to develop a program to meet the needs that face a proprietor to properly protect their business.  His current role is Director Of Operations for Tilton, Thomas & Morgan’s Bowling Insurance Program and works out of their Texas office.

Cheryl Raley

Cheryl Raley joined the agency in 2001 to assist with direct mail marketing and quickly made herself indispensable. She handles all the licensing with State Agencies for the company, processes all agency correspondence, works with brokers for quotes and coverages and is the first person to answer the phone when someone calls. Cheryl is incredibly well organized and is the spark plug that keeps the day to day operations humming along.  She is a licensed agent and a student of the package policies and the coverages that we market.


Bowling Center Insurance

Our business has been built based on deliberate and unparalleled customer service. A real dedication to and a firm vision of a niche marketing program has made us a major player in the recreation insurance marketplace. Not just the longevity, but we visit with our clientele either at National & Regional events or in person at their business place. We maintain exclusive contracts with our carriers so that we can give that little extra value added and have continuity among and with our clients and their insurance contracts. We love our business and it shows!

Judy Koehler

Judy Koehler has been in the insurance field since 1973 when she joined an agency as a High School Student. Little did she know that there was no escape from the insurance business. She has been a full partner, director and agent in the agency since 1995. Judy handles all matters related to accounting and all producer and company communications and relationships. She has attended numerous Bowling and Family Recreation Center events and is well known in the industry.

M. Tyler Morgan

Tilton, Thomas and Morgan Inc. got its start in 1946 when Pat Whitaker joined Clive Reagan to form the Reagan-Whitaker Insurance Agency. Our first office was located on Edmond Street in St. Joseph in the Electric Theater Building. In 1952, Jack Wright joined the Agency and shortly thereafter the offices were moved to 212 N. 7th Street in downtown St. Joseph, MO.  Don Tilton joined the Agency in 1958 and Byron Thomas in 1968. In 1978 Pat Whitaker sold the Agency to Don, Byron and Jack. Wayne Morgan later joined the Agency in 1981.  In 1998 Don Tilton and Byron Thomas retired and Wayne purchased their interest in the Company. That same year, Tyler Morgan joined the Agency, becoming partner in 2000. In 2002, our offices moved to the current site at 1802 Union.  In 2010 Wayne Morgan retired and Tyler Morgan purchased his interest in the Company.

After the unexpected passing of Bill Taylor, Tilton, Thomas & Morgan merged with Bill Taylor & Associates.  The firm is one of a select few agency partners to offer the BPAA Endorsed Insurance Program through Specialty Insurance Group (SIG), the endorsed carrier of the BPAA.